Section 2 Deregulation in the Transport Sector and Improvement of Social Capital


1. Implementation Status and Effects of Deregulation

(1) Deregulation in Trucking Businesses
(A) Outline of deregulation
    The Trucking Business Law (enforced on December 1, 1990) abolished the supply-demand control regulation and changed the licensing system to a permission system for new entrants. With regard to freight charges and rates, the approval system was replaced by a notification system. Thus, economic regulations for this industry were substantially eased. On the other hand, social regulations were strengthened to ensure transport safety.
(B) Effects of deregulation
(a) Market vitalization
    After the law was enforced, the number of newly participated operators increased (Fig. 1).
    Because of intensified competition, both the actual operating rate and the actual carriage rate have been on the decline, and the tonnage per operating truck also decreased. As a result, transport efficiency is declining (Fig. 2).
    With the progress of deregulation, however, we can see vitalization in the market, such as expansion of mixed freight transport.
(b) Decline in actual carriage charges
    Operating revenue per tonnage-kilometer and other revenues decreased, and actual carriage charges continue to decline (Fig. 3).
(c) Improved productivity
    The number of employees increased, but the increase was lower than the rate of increase in the volume of freight traffic. The added value per employee also increased (Fig. 4).
(d) Diversified services
    New parcel services are now provided because of intensified competition among operators, such as "refrigerated" home delivery and specified-time home delivery.    
    In addition new moving services have also appeared, such as moving packages for transferees leaving their families behind.

(2) Deregulation in Aviation Businesses
(A) Outline of deregulation
    Double-tracking and triple-tracking were introduced to more domestic lines.
    Airline companies introduced advanced purchase discount prices for domestic lines from May 1995, and implemented a fare range system between May and June 1996.
(B) Effects of deregulation
(a) Increased passengers
    Of the twenty-four air routes which were changed to double-tracking or triple-tracking from April 1991 to April 1996, sixteen routes saw a higher rate of increase in actual passengers during the year following the change, than the average rate of increase during the previous three years.
(b) Diversified fares and decline in real fares
    The introduction of early purchase discount fares and fare range systems resulted in changes in fares depending on seasonality, flight time, and purchase time. Thus, the diversification of fares was accelerated.
    Revenues from fares per passenger-kilometer continued to decline after FY 1992 (Fig. 5).
(c) Improved convenience through increased number of flights
    As more airline companies extended their services thanks to double-tracking and triple-tracking, the number of flights increased, resulting in improved convenience to users.
(d) Improved productivity
    Operating expenditures per available tonnage-kilometer have been on the decline since FY 1991. Volume of passenger traffic per employee is on the increase (Fig. 6).
    In response to intensified competition, airline companies began to cancel or reduce flights on unprofitable routes, while increasing the number of flights on competitive routes.
(e) Balanced demand
    Airline companies tried to balance demand and raise transport efficiency by changing fares according to season and time zone.
    In 1996, following the introduction of a fare range system, a large portion of demand shifted from August, when fares are higher because of the large numbers of passengers, to July and September (Fig. 7).

(3) Deregulation in the Taxi Industry
(A) Outline of deregulation
    With regard to the number of vehicles, which is used to control supply and demand, the following two measures were implemented in order to facilitate new entries into the market :
1) A fixed percentage was added to the total number of vehicles in each area, and
2) The minimum number of vehicles companies are required to own was reduced.
    With regard to fares and pricing, a zone-tariff system was introduced, for which different ceiling rates are to be calculated for each zone on the basis of the average cost method. In addition, a shortening of the distance used to calculate the initial fare was also a p proved.
(B) Effects of deregulation
(a) A more diversified fare system
    By the end of March of 1997, 35 out of 77 pricing blocks across the nation put multiple pricing systems into effect. Also, various services such as discount rates have been introduced.
    With the introduction of the zone-tariff system, there is now a larger variety of fares and pricing systems available.
(b) Stimulating the industry with the introduction of more flexible supply-demand control
    The control standard has become more flexible since FY 1997. For example, an announcement was made, increasing the limit on the total number of vehicles in the Tokyo area by as much as 3,000, while the minimun number of vehicles each company is required to own was reduced. This increase in flexibility is expected to attract new entrants into the market for the first time in 33 years.

(4) Other Deregulation
(A) Review of regulations--for reducing physical distribution costs
(a) With regard to entry regulations on truck terminals, the licensing system was changed to a permission system, and the regulations on charges and others were substantially eased.
(b) For railway freight charges, the Ministry introduced an upper limit price regulation based on full-cost principles from February 1997.
(c) The Cabinet meeting decided to phase out over tonnage adjustments in the coastal shipping business. With the revision of the Coastal Shipping Association Law , the Coastal shipping Association was able to underwrite the ship building debts from June 1997.
    Substantial portions of the Agreement on Coastal shipping Rate were abolished by the end of November 1996.
(B) Review of regulations--for improving passenger transport services
(a) Easier entry to businesses
    With regard to the supply-demand control standards for chartered bus businesses, measures were taken from FY 1997 for approving the increase of vehicles in business zones whose actual operation rate was higher than a certain level.
(b) Flexible setting of fares and charges
    Deregulation of railway and bus fares/charges has enabled companies to adjust fares and charges flexibly according to demand. For example, they introduced discounts for bus to subway connections, a commuter pass valid only during the summer vacation, off-season discount domestic passenger ship fares, and the reduction in some express train fares and green car fares.
    For passenger railway services, an upper limit price regulation was introduced based on full-cost principles from January 1997, resulting in reduced fares on parallel routes.
(C) Review of regulations --for improving quality of life
(a) Road Vehicles Act was revised, which simplified the inspection and maintenance system from July 1995. In addition to the increase in "User Inspections", maintenance services are being diversified and the basic rates for vehicle maintenance are declining (Fig. 8).
(b) Online systems installed at convenience stores and other stores enabled the sale of "agent-organized tours" and other items from June 1997.

2. Effects of Social Capital Improvement

(1) Trunk Line Traffic
(A) Trunk railways
    The Yamagata Shinkansen Line, which offers through operation between Tokyo and Yamagata, shortened the time needed to travel between the two cities by 42 minutes, and also eliminated the inconvenience of changing trains at Fukushima. The number of passengers increased about 40% after the new line was opened.
    On the other hand, the number of air passengers decreased between Tokyo and Yamagata, but the total number of people moving between the two places increased. This means that the traffic network has been improved enabling users to utilize the advantages of both aviation and railway services (Table 9).
(B) Domestic aviation services
    With regard to the offshore development activities at Tokyo International Airport (Haneda Airport), the new runway C was opened in March 1997. This runway increased capacity by 40 flights per day. As a result, some companies are trying to establish new regular air transport businesses.
    Based on the report by the Committee for the Slot Allocation of Tokyo International Airport, forty flights were distributed among operators, resulting in increased services.     It also became possible to operate flights around the clock, including midnight and early morning flights.
    The extension of railway lines into airports provided users with easier access at many airports. For example, at Fukuoka Airport, nearly half of the airport users began to use the railway after the subway line was extended into the airport (Fig. 10).


Note : User Inspection is a type of motor vehicle inspection in which motor vehicle users take their own vehicles to Local Land Transport Offices for inspection without utilizing of service garages.


(C) High-speed bus
    With the progress of expressway construction, high-speed bus networks are being enhanced. In Kyushu, for example, the completion of the Kyushu Expressway shortened driving time and increased passengers. In addition, intensified competition among different means of transportation led to increased speed, as well as the introduction of reduced fares and freight rates for buses, railways and airplanes.
(2) Metropolitan Transportation
    On the Isezaki line of the Tobu Railway, for example, the line between Takenotsuka and Koshigaya was changed to a four-track line, and major improvement work was completed at Kitasenju station, resulting in better services : more trains running, relieved congestion, and trains running faster during the morning rush hours.

(3) International Transportation
(A) Construction of airports
    At Kansai International Airport, the number of users has increased since its opening, and new routes and flights have successively been added.
    The number of foreigners who use Kansai International Airport increased substantial-ly (Fig. 11), and an increasing number of residents in the Kinki district departed Japan via this airport.
    Freight traffic in the Kansai district also increased considerably, in terms of both quantity and share (Fig. 12).
(B) Construction of ports and harbors
    As more and more large-sized container ships are plying between Asia and Europe/ North America, the two berth of the container terminal with the depth of 15 meters was opened at Kobe port in April 1996. At present, harbor facilities are also being urgently constructed at the gate-way ports, such as Tokyo and Yokohama.
    At subsidiary gate-way ports in eight districts throughout Japan, international container terminals are also strategically being constructed to help businesses reduce physical distribution costs.


Back TopPage Next